My Sugar Menu South Africa

From the mind of the chocolatier Kaylah Greenberg, and late chef Asher Isaacs, their wacky brainchild: The Sugar. My Sugar Menu combines innovative traditional techniques with artistry while making sure to keep the vibe of the store comfortable.

This eatery handcrafts each item in-house with care, using only the finest ingredients in the world, with a twist.

They hand-craft their chocolates with a twist, they handle each doughnut with care, they take each confectionary seriously, and they can wrap this all up in a gift box. For every occasion, they offer beautiful gift packaging that will let your recipient know how much you care for them.

Here are My Sugar menu prices in South Africa:

Menu ItemsPrice (R)


Apple Crumb Doughnut35
Banoffee Donut35
Eaton Mess Doughnut35
Peppermint Crisp Tart Doughnut35
Tiramisu Doughnut35
Lemon Miringue Doughnut35
Milk Tart Doughnut35
Creme Brulee Doughnut35
Cookies 'N Creme Doughnut35
Peanut Butter Doughnut35

Build Your Own

Build Your Own Box - 10 Pieces160
Build Your Own Box - 15 Pieces240
Build Your Own Box - 25 Pieces400


Chocolate Brownie35
Cheesecake Brownie35


Salty Sweet Pretzel Bark (Dark Chocolate)45
Salty Sweet Pretzel Bark (Milk Chocolate)45
Rock 'n Roll65
Butterscotch Popcorn55
Caramelized Coconut Chips65

Hand-crafted Chocolates

Black Chai19
Berry Baby (Vegan)16
Cashew Coconut16
Choc-Work Orange (Vegan)16
Cookie Brian25
Cosmic Coconut16
Creamy Coffee16
Hazel Coriander19
Hazelnut Espresso (Vegan)19
Marshmallow Bombs29
Mr. Robot25
Rainbow Cookie19
Space Bar29
The Skull25

About My Sugar

My Sugar is a food establishment mainly focusing on serving chocolates. The sweets shop started serving its products to the public in 2015. Their flagship store was founded in Sea Point, specializing in hand-painted chocolate bon pons, mouth-watering doughnuts filled with only the best desserts, and flavorful milkshakes drizzled and topped with their house-original confectionery.

All of these are paired with their exclusive coffee blend, making sure to leave their customers with a smile. In November 2019, they opened a brand new chocolate bar in the newest Checkers flagship store in Constantia.

My Sugar Menu Best Seller

If we’re talking about sweets and chocolates, then we can’t leave out the brownie. The store offers different kinds of brownies for you to try, such as the classic Chocolate Brownie. 

Cheesecake Brownie My Sugar Menu

If you don’t want something entirely made with chocolate, then they have just the thing for you. Up next, they have the cheesecake brownie. It’s a crispy-edge brownie, with a center filled with baked cheesecake, sipped in chocolate ganache. 

My Sugar also lets you “Build Your Own Box.” This item lets you fill up a box with sweets of your choice. You can choose the sweets that you know you, and/or your recipient will love. It comes in boxes of 10, 15, and 25 pieces. You won’t have to worry about buying too little or too much, because they give you the option to pick the amount. 

A familiar name that anybody would love to buy is the cookies ‘n cream doughnut. This hand-rolled doughnut is yeast-based, filled with white chocolate, and crushed chocolate cookie mousse. They top this doughnut with chocolate ganache, a baby chocolate chip cookie, and a brownie bite.

Last, but not least the best sellers, offer Butterscotch Popcorn. Come on, who isn’t in the mood for flavored popcorn? They’re perfect for snacks, movies, dates, and more! It’s the perfect balance between sweets and snacks. My Sugar has more to offer than its bestsellers. Each item is as good as the rest, and only your preference sets them apart from each other!

My Sugar Menu Doughnuts

First of all, let’s start off with an appetizing name: The Apple Crumble Doughnut. This doughnut is guaranteed to be as good as it sounds. The Apple Crumble Doughnut is a traditional yeast-based doughnut. It’s filled with cinnamon custard and roasted apples. Finally, the doughnut is topped with a buttery crumble. 

Up next, the My Sugar offers a unique flavor pairing in their own take on Banoffee Doughnuts menu. This traditional yeast-based doughnut is filled to the brim with caramelized banana mousse that will leave you floating in dreamy, sweety goodness. It has a hidden caramel center, and all of these are topped with caramelized banana chips. 

Peanut Butter Doughnut Menu

Another must-try, the mouth-watering donut is their Peanut Butter Doughnut. Who doesn’t like classic peanut butter and chocolate combinations? This doughnut is hand-rolled and yeast-based. It’s filled with peanut butter, and milk chocolate mousse. The shop tops this off with peanut butter ganache, and its high-quality homemade peanut brittle. 

My Sugar Menu Chocolates

The shop offers a variety of chocolates, one unique chocolate they offer is the Black Chai. This chocolate is caramelized with chocolate ganache in a dark chocolate shell, infused with black chai tea. 

If you’re vegan, then no problem. The sweets store makes sure that there’s an item for anybody and everybody who enters their establishment. The Berry Baby is a vegan chocolate option. The Berry Baby is made with tart raspberry, as well as dark chocolate ganache coated in a dark chocolate shell.

Unique chocolate is the caramello buddha. Have you ever tried eating buddha-shaped chocolate? Ever wonder if it tastes just as good? Whichever your answer may be, you still have to try this one out! The caramel buddha consists of miso caramel and crushed peanuts. This chocolate is coated with a milk chocolate shell.

Confectionery Menu

Let’s start things off with a simple confectionery, the Salty Sweet Pretzel Bark (Dark Chocolate). This salty pretzel is coated in yummy, gooey caramel, which the shop coats in milk or dark chocolate, sprinkled with maldon sea salt. You can also get this confectionery in another flavor, milk chocolate.

My Sugar Menu Delivery

The shop does its best to serve your food as fast as possible. They have top-of-the-line service strategies that enable them to utilize their efforts effectively. If you want your order to be served to your doorstep, then you’re in luck. My Sugar Menu is finally taking your orders through the Mr. Yum app. All their food comes from their Sea Point Branch and their Claremont Branch. You can learn more about “My Sugar” on their official website.


If you’re looking for something to hit that sweet tooth, then look no further than the menu of My Sugar. They offer everything, from chocolates, sweets, and confectioneries, down to the gift packaging you can send them in. They offer the completely sweet experience that everybody deserves to have. Every once in a while, it’s okay to let loose, and eat as many sweets as you want. Whenever you feel like having a cheat day, then they get your back.

If you’re ever in the area, you should definitely try out one of their delicious treats, and they’ll be waiting for you to come in their doors. You have the choice, so choose the My Sugar now.